It’s been a long time coming but MLB The Show is finally back on portables. The last time baseball fans were able to play the premiere baseball sim on the way back in 2015, which was the last year the series was released on the PlayStation Vita.
The PS Vita version was far behind the PlayStation 3 and PlayStation 4 version by a large margin in pretty much every way but one: it was portable. Back then, it was easy to look past the graphical downgrade and the struggles of trying to play a hit about a small ball on a small screen because it was counter-balanced with the huge convenience being able to play on the go.
Seven years later and, honestly, not much has changed with the Switch version. The good news is that, like the PS Vita version, the switch version is very capable of playing MLB The Show 22 on the go without any major issues. And also, unlike the PS Vita, the switch version has the obvious advantage of docking in if you’re not using a Switch Lite.
The thing is, though, regardless of whether you choose to play handheld or docked, the experience is more or less the same. There’s a noticeable visual performance downgrade from not only the PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X versions, but even the last-gen via the PS4. This shouldn’t come as a surprise to anyone considering, you know, the switch is a last-gen console.
There is some noticeable stutter in-between pitches but to be fair, it usually clears up when the action starts back up. If I didn’t run into any major problems hitting, fielding, or pitching, the switch would just continue to struggle in cutscenes. Whether I played in handheld or docked mode, it was a serviceable baseball experience, but very far from competing with any other version of the game.
You should really only be putting yourself through this inferior experience if you check at least one of these two boxes. They should both be obvious.
One, the switch is the only console you can play on MLB The Show 22. If you’re a Nintendo fan through and through and don’t own a PS4, PS5, or Xbox Series X, then, yeah, this is as good as it is going to get. Don’t worry, it’s not a horrible experience and it’s definitely better than RBI Baseball, that’s for sure.
Second, even if you have another platform to play on MLB The Show 22, if you’re really keen on playing the idea of MLB The Show 22, then it might be worth a pickup. The Switch version, though flawed and inferior, is still better overall than any of the PS Vita versions. Visually, it looks closer to the PS4 version than the PS Vita version ever did, the switch controls are better than the PS Vita’s, the screen is bigger and easier to see on the pitches, and you have the option to dock it depending on your model.
The real question is whether or not you should pick up the Switch version if you also have access to a current-gen version of MLB The Show 22. In this scenario, which happens to be my own, it’s really a personal call.
There were some years when I was addicted to playing through Franchise, I would have been killed for a switch version back then so I could knock a game or two out of my season no matter where I was.
On the other hand, there were some years when I played a ton of Diamond Dynasty online. There is no way I would willingly choose to play online on the switch if I had the option to play it on a PS5 or Xbox Series X instead. Playing baseball online is a painful enough experience sometimes even on the most powerful platforms how effective timing and lag are more than in any other sports game. I don’t want to sacrifice any more visual fidelity or performance than I have.
All that is just to say basically, it is situational. If you can only choose one, you should probably just go ahead and get the PS5 or Xbox Series X version. But if you have the luxury of being able to afford a switch and current-gen version of MLB The Show 22 and can see yourself playing on the go, then go ahead and grab ’em both, you probably won’t regret it.